GeoElmo6000: While I was planning to restore this cache, in the end I'm going to just archive it, as I don't really care to maintain this cache anymore. I was able to recover and restore this cache and perhaps I'll use it in a future geocache.
I really enjoyed creating the puzzle, a geocaching Minecraft video I posted on my YouTube channel called "Geo Elmo Geocaching". While the cache may be archived, the video still can be seen on my channel through the link on this page. It's a fun Christmas-Minecraft-geocaching video.
Thanks to everyone who took the time to find this. It wound up with 75 finds and 18 favorite points, which was a nice 26% of premium cacher finds.